video

sound

Persian Version

View:

251

Download:

0

Cites:

Information Journal Paper

Title

A CRITIQUE OF POPULAR VIEW ABOUT SURAH MA'ARIJ AS BEING MECCAN

Author(s)

 KARIMI MAHALLI TAHEREH

Pages

  225-240

Abstract

 There are two different views about whether SURAH MA’AREJ is MECCAN or MEDINAN, one is popular and the other unpopular. The proponents of popular view believe that the whole Surah is MECCAN. On the contrary, the proponents of unpopular view emphasize that the whole surah or at least a part of it is MEDINAN. Each group provides different arguments to prove their view. The present paper seeks to evaluate the claims and arguments of both groups, using a library-descriptive method, reviewing different Shia and Sunni interpretations, reviewing the occasions of revelation of these verses in the Surah, and elaborating on the relationship between the verses. Of course, in doing so, it mainly focuses on Sunni resources. The reviews reveal that the POPULAR OPINION has not decisive and absolute arguments, that it is not true to regard the aforementioned Surah as MECCAN, and that insistence on SURAH MA’AREJ as being MECCAN by its proponents is based on theological, religious or sectarian motivations.

Cites

  • No record.

    • References

  • No record.

    • Related Journal Papers

    Related Seminar Papers

  • No record.

    • Related Plans

  • No record.

    • Recommended Workshops

    Cite

    APA: Copy

    KARIMI MAHALLI, T. (2017). A CRITIQUE OF POPULAR VIEW ABOUT SURAH MA'ARIJ AS BEING MECCAN. JOURNAL OF COMPARATIVE TAFSIR STUDIES, 3(1 (5) ), 225-240. https://sid.ir/paper/267065/en

    Vancouver: Copy

    KARIMI MAHALLI TAHEREH. A CRITIQUE OF POPULAR VIEW ABOUT SURAH MA'ARIJ AS BEING MECCAN. JOURNAL OF COMPARATIVE TAFSIR STUDIES. 2017 [cited 2023January29];3(1 (5) ):225-240. Available from: https://sid.ir/paper/267065/en

    IEEE: Copy

    KARIMI MAHALLI, T., 2017. A CRITIQUE OF POPULAR VIEW ABOUT SURAH MA'ARIJ AS BEING MECCAN. JOURNAL OF COMPARATIVE TAFSIR STUDIES, [online] 3(1 (5) ), pp.225-240. Available: https://sid.ir/paper/267065/en.






    File Not Exists.